Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Walking a dog that never stops pulling is a nightmare. It only gets worse and worse if you live with relatively big ones. Normal collars are no longer a solution when they keep breaking free in as little as five minutes. So, it’s time you get them the best dog collar for pulling that will teach them to behave.

Scroll down for more details on what the market has for most effective (and safest) neck accessories for your furry buddies!

What’s the Best Dog Collar For Pulling in 2021?

1. Coun​​​​try​​​​ Brook Petz ​​​​B009WADWRW: Best Overal​​​​

2. PetSafe​​​​ ​​​​Ge​​​​ntle Leader Headcollar B00074L4W2: Best for Preventing Choking​​​​

3. Max and Neo Chain Collar B01HSNDPYE: Best for Night Walks

4. StarMark Training Collar B000A6BD5K: Best for Calming Hyper Dogs

5. Mighty Paw Cinch Chain Collar B01N5MQ2E8: Best for All-day Use

6. PetSafe Chic Gentle Leader Headcollar B01N7FKFY7: Best for Design

7. Canny Dog Walking and Training Collar B00F0J9RMS: Best for Steering

8. Herm Sprenger Prong Dog Training Collar B07VMNFVQN: Best for Anti-slipping: Best for Steering

9. CollarDirect Reflective Collar B0845QPH5D: Best for Puppies

10. Dazzber Extra Strong Dog Collar B07YY9323F: Best for XLarge Dogs

Top 10 Best Dog Collar for Pulling:

Here are the 10 picks of Best Dog Collar for Pulling that will give you hope:  

#1 Country Br​ook Petz B009​WADWRW: Best Overal​​​​​​

It’s hard to get your hands on a product putting your hyper buddies under control while feeling softer than any other collars. But this Country Brook Petz is where you can find all those specific traits.

Designed with no buckle, this collar slips over the head. Generally, it’s an endless loop that can be adjusted through the welded stainless steel rings which will immediately tighten in response to pull. And you will be thrilled to know that there is no limit to what dogs this can train. The collar can fit Maltese puppies at its tightest and fit up to an English Golden Retriever at its loosest.   

What’s more brilliant is the box stitching applied to the pressure points. This will add a double strength to the collar so you don’t need to worry about it being frayed by big dogs. What’s more, the heavy nylon material is extremely durable but still gives out a soft feeling at the same time. It’s not only comfy but also won’t scratch your dog’s neck.

81sijjqaTVL. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

There’re almost no complaints about this Country Brook Petz collar except for some pointy edged metal rings on the inside that can cause discomfort. Make sure you double check before putting it on your dog.

Pros

  • Solid design
  • Well-fitted
  • Low chance of break or fray

Cons

  • Some metallic edges on the inside

#2 PetSafe Gentle Leader Headcollar B00074L4W2: Best for Preventing Choking

Despite its over-simplistic impression, PetSafe Gentle Leader prevents pulling better than people expected. Consisting of a strap placed around the nose and another loop around the neck, this collar works best in redirecting your buddy’s tendency to pull without choking or gagging them.

The miracle lays is a special padded neoprene nose loop which places pressure on the back of the neck instead of the throat. Whenever they attempt to lunge forward, the headcollar will immediately place gentle pressure on pain-free points. The thoughtful detail is all dog lovers need, as it shows our pets they have crossed the limit without them going through pain.

Having such a convenient design is also quite a nice selling point. The collar never squeezes too tight for your dogs’ comfort, giving them the freedom to move their jaws and even bark.

However, this PetSafe Gentle Leader will only make the difference as long as you take the exact measurement of your dog’s neck and nose. 

51JtwsoLH9L. AC SL1024 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • Great functionality
  • Highly adjustable to different dog sizes
  • Not cause choking and gagging

Cons

  • Require precise measurements

#3 Max and Neo Chain Collar B01HSNDPYE: Best for Night Walks

This special Max and Neo Chain Collar stands out with a 2mm stylish nylon band with a stainless steel chain at the back and a well-built snap buckle, completed with 2 reflective stitching bands that increase visibility during night walks. You can release your dogs halfway in a less crowded area for them to have some fun on their own, and still manage to have them under your view the whole time.

But even with reflective features, it would be dangerous if your dog breaks out and takes off running into the night. That is why the producer has made this collar to be extremely secure. Unlike some buckles that snap easily, it has a lockable tab on it, which curtails the motion and prevents unexpected release.

516hAvtoe%2BL. AC SL1000 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Being a martingale collar whose whole point is to tighten just in time when your dogs prepare to lunge forward, it also serves the purpose of pull prevention very well.

However, there is still a minor problem. The chain appears to be shorter than you think, making it difficult to slip this collar on large-sized dogs.

Pros

  • Durable, high-quality materials
  • Metal slider for length adjustment
  • Make noticeable sound when the dogs pull

Cons

  • Short chain

#4 StarMark Training Collar B000A6BD5K: Best for Calming Hyper Dogs

This unique looking StarMark Collar is made to play the role of an effective communicator between you and your energetic furry friends, telling them to stop lunging and freaking pedestrians out during walks. 

Made from superb heavy polymer, the collar looks just like a flat collar on the outside. The intention behind this design is to make your pulling-loving dogs look less dangerous to people. 

On the inside, there are several removable pronged links applying gentle pressure around your dog’s neck as a silent command for them to stop pulling. The design works well as a replacement for the infamous metal pinched collar that answers to your dogs’ disobedience with pain, which is the last thing we want.

61pN4kHa56L. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

However, there is still a chance of this StarMark Training Collar being snapped on an extra strong dog. We would not recommend it for large Pitbull or playful Golden Retriever owners.

Pros

  • Manufactured by dog experts
  • Gentle pressure
  • Help with training

Cons

  • Risk of snapping for larger breed

#5 Mighty Paw Cinch Chain Collar B01N5MQ2E8: Best for All-day Use

This Mighty Paw Collar has all the qualities you look for in a daily use collar, ranging from the durable nylon band to the iron chain. It forms a comfortable loop around your dogs’ necks, and they can go about their days without even realizing there is an anti-pull tool on their body.

That side of the collar will only be activated during walkies. Its most notable feature is the auto-cinch that immediately tightens under tension, but the squeeze is gentle enough so that it will not cause choke. Besides, the stitching is also reflective, which allows you to keep your eyes on the pups when taking them out at night.

61Q4OUhemUL. AC SL1000 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

There is also an additional D-ring attachment to switch it from a training to a standard collar. With this smart design, your dog can wear the same collar all day without any discomfort.

However, it is not all that effective on giant dogs since the producers did not release any size larger than 8 x 1 x 2 inches.

Pros

  • Multi-functional
  • A high level of comfort
  • Martingale style for choking prevention

Cons

  • No size for big breeds

#6 PetSafe Chic Gentle Leader Headcollar B01N7FKFY7: Best for Design

This PetSafe Chic Gentle Leader will first appeal to people who want to add more style to a regular dull-looking collar. As you can see, all dogs’ training tools, including collars, always border on the verge of boring with only one solid color. You can consider this as a change of pace if they have never been to your liking.

The collar is more than a mere fashion statement, for its well-made anti-pull mechanism can stop your dogs from tugging during walks by tightening to an acceptable extent. The nose loop and a neck strap might look like they will get in the way, but they never prevent barking or eating activities in reality. This allows your dogs to explore the outdoors to their fullest.

Moreover, this collar is also designed to be put on super easily. All you need to do is slip it over the nose to the neck, then fasten the nose loop and then the neck strap to ensure it won’t get loose.

But this collar is far from the most perfect option. Some customers reported that the collar they purchased didn’t fit their small dogs as the neck strap came untight. Therefore, I wouldn’t recommend you buy this PetSafe Chic Gentle Leader for your tiny puppies. 

816GpLVSU%2BL. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • Gentle control
  • Anti-biting
  • Easy to put on

Cons

  • Unsuitable for small dogs

#7 Canny Dog Walking and Training Collar B00F0J9RMS: Best for Steering

Another simple headcollar design namely Canny Dog Walking and Training Collar is best known for its astonishing power. This collar is made to halt even the worst puller without causing breathing trouble with its well-built and durable material. We are sure that you will love how this one eases the pain in your arm when resisting tension from the pulling dog. 

Also, should you realize the nose strap is not tight enough, you can find a yellow slider beneath the dog’s muzzle to adjust the tightness and more ways to put your playful dogs in control.

Overall, we must say this Canny Collar is a must-have tool to keep your puller dog under control. Only one minor flaw is that this collar doesn’t work well on dogs that pull with their noses. The nose loop might come loose and get into their eyes.

61Qf6mb iIL. AC SL1315 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • Extra strength
  • Neat and minimal design
  • Easy to wear

Cons

  • Nose loop may loosens

#8 Herm Sprenger Prong Dog Training Collar B07VMNFVQN: Best for Anti-slipping: Best for Steering

This fabulous Herm Sprenger Prong Collar looks just like a torture tool at first sight, but do not let that get to you, for it is also the furthest thing from painful. Made up of several non-pinching prongs, this collar will hold firmly onto the dog’s neck and resists from slipping.

Moreover, it consists of removable links which have a center fastener plate to keep the prongs always in the same direction, limiting the possibility of them coming apart even when your dogs get overexcited. This will certainly aid training and correction of negative behavior, and has been tested by professional dog trainers

A piece of advice. This is only our personal opinion but we think you should purchase the stainless steel version which costs a few dollars more than the chrome coated one. It will last for a lifetime.

However, this Herm Sprenger Prong Collar is also said to take many tries to be put on, so expect quite a learning curve

71aQSFTDfkL. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • For dogs of all sizes
  • Non-pinching prongs
  • Anti-rust design

Cons

  • Tricky to wear on

#9 CollarDirect Reflective Collar B0845QPH5D: Best for Puppies

This economical CollarDirect Reflective Collar is made from non-allergic material to help puppies get used to wearing a collar. It is also praised for being extremely lightweight so that it won’t weigh down the puppies’ neck during training.

If you are into minimal design, you will love how this collar can be worn on quickly and be worn as a normal collar after putting off leash. Besides, the material is super durable and eliminates the risk of discoloration, while the stitching work on the nylon band is totally reflective to serve night walks.

Similar to all options in this list, this useful collar can help with your dog correction training. Its martingale style applies just the right amount of pressure to get your young pups to realize that pulling is not an encouraged behavior, and cease to do so as they grow up.

However, as of its purpose, this CollarDirect is not suitable for large and strong dogs as it may break under tension.

813qhzek2%2BL. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • Safe and durable
  • Extremely lightweight
  • Easy to put on

Cons

  • Not recommended for strong pullers

#10 Dazzber Extra Strong Dog Collar B07YY9323F: Best for XLarge Dogs

The name speaks for itself. This Dazzber Extra Strong Collar is built especially for extremely large dogs. When your buddy outgrows almost every collar the market can possibly offer, this one will save the day.

Made of superb durable 1000D nylon with a total thickness of 3.8mm, the colar is wide and enough to hold down massive dogs. Additionally, it is designed with no buckle to prevent snapping by accidental force.

When going out for a walk, you will love how a stitch box is put at every pressure point to avoid choking. This caring and safe anti-pull system is a must-have for all big dogs, since they can easily escape regular collars with one single jerk of the neck.

The good news is, few past customers ever experienced a breakdown of this product. However, there are some complaints on this collar being uncomfortable during normal, daily wear.

71I3PnzW59L. AC SL1500 Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Freebutton check price on amazon Best Dog Collar For Pulling That Keep Your Walks Struggle-Free

Pros

  • Stylish look with name tag
  • Metal hardware for extra durability
  • No buckle to prevent escape

Cons

  • Only work for training purposes

How to choose the Best Dog Collar for Pulling?

If you’re still pondering on how to choose the Best Dog Collar for Pulling, I’ve got your back!

Types

Generally, there are 3 types of Martingale, namely headcollar, pinch collar and chain collar.

As for headcollar, it is probably the most gentle collar for pulling dogs. The collar doesn’t squeeze the neck and nose, thus not causing choking and coughing.

Pinch collars are more common when it comes to training aggressive dogs. Despite its appearance, in fact, it doesn’t cause any actual pain for your pups. Instead, the collar applies just enough pressure to calm them down.

You can also opt for chain collars if you prefer some warning in advance. Thanks to the clanking sound, you will know right away whenever your dogs are up to something.

Recommended Serial

It’s widely known that synthesis fiber bands are more comfy and less likely to injure, but it’s easier to fray than metal. If your dog is a master of biting and snapping collars, it’s best to stick to a chain for more durability. 

Suitable Size

As for most Martingales and anti-pull collars, the effort will amount to nothing unless you choose the correct size. By correct size, it means a tight fit around your dog’s nose or neck but not tight enough for them to have problems breathing. 

To find the perfect size for your dog, I would recommend that you measure the top portion of the neck and press down through his fur to get the precise measurement. Remember this rule of thumb: You have to be able to insert two fingers between the collar and your dogs’ neck.

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are the most frequently asked questions on Best Dog Collar for Pulling: 

What type of collar is the best choice for a dog that pulls?

For strong and big dogs like Belgian dogs and English Golden Retrievers, an average collar that wraps around the neck would break in no time as the dog starts pulling. 

Therefore, most owners will switch to a Martingale – a collar that specialized in preventing pull by applying subtle pressure to the neck and nose. Each dog has his unique preference, he refuses a type of collar but gets used to another one immediately.

I would suggest you try at least 3 different types of collars to find out what the best one is.

How can you stop your dog from pulling when walking?

It’s hard to tell a dog to stop pulling, especially when they’re too excited to join the outside world. In this case, all you need to do is a little training with a proper Martingale and some treats to make sure he behaves.

Is it better to use a harness or collar?

A harness is also one of the options for dogs that like to pull. The perks of harness are durability and safety. Without doubt, it will definitely last longer than a collar and can hold off your dog better.

On the other hand, a collar is a much more comfortable choice since it does not put any pressure on your dogs’ torso. If you do not have a dog with a tendency to turn violent and believe a harness is just too much, then a collar is totally what you should go after.

That’s wrapped it up

Now you’ve got through our list, you will be able to find the collar that best suits your buddy’s body shape as well as his temper. Overall, I would definitely recommend the Country Brook Petz for its sturdy design and durable material.

Also, for the first time putting on a collar, you will need to make careful adjustments so that it won’t cause any discomfort. For the collars with buckles, always double check before going out to prevent accidental release. Even the best dog collar for pulling will not be of any help if it cannot fit your dogs in the beginning.